The BEST EVER Creamy Lemon Pie

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

My twist on Joanna Gaine’s famous magnolia lemon pie — a thick graham cracker crust with a creamy rich lemon filling and fresh whipped cream on top. This truly is the BEST creamy lemon pie ever — everyone begs for the recipe! 

My twist on Joanna Gaine's famous magnolia lemon pie

Creamy Lemon Pie

Yes, I’m one of the millions of fans obsessed with the Gaine’s family. I’ve loved their show over the years, have way too many dishes from her collection, and have been in love with her famous fresh lemon pie.  I have a good amount of lemon desserts that I’ve shared over the years and make all too frequently, but when I read about Joanna’s famous lemon pie, I knew I had to try it. And she was right, it did not disappoint!

In fact, we’ve made it so many times and I’ve tweaked so many aspects of it, I thought it was worth sharing with you my changes. While this pie is still quite true to her original recipe, there are enough some variations that I believe really make this lemon pie go from great to WOW. 🙂

I’m definitely a chocolate person, but if there is one thing that can get me away from chocolate, it’s lemon. If you’ve made more than a few of my recipes, you know I use lemon A LOT — savory and sweet. This easy lemon pie might even out-rank some of my favorite chocolate desserts!

Tweaking Joanna’s lemon pie with sweetened condensed milk:

  • The biggest thing I felt the pie was lacking was overall lemon flavor. The lemon was a bit too faint for me and so I decided to try increasing the lemon juice. When that didn’t quite do it, I started adding in some lemon emulsion (which ended a little too strong) and finally I ended up on adding some lemon extract. The extra lemon juice and a bit of lemon extract takes this from being faintly lemon to a “pucker-up, this is definitely a lemon” treat. It’s not overpowering, but much more present and flavorful.
  • Her recipe also calls for just over 2 cans of sweetened condensed milk which obviously makes this real lemon pie super sweet. The extra lemon and lemon extract help to balance that sweetness a bit better. I also reduce the sweetened condensed milk to cut that sweetness just a bit and to avoid the waste of a leftover half-filled can of sweetened condensed milk (I was never quite sure how to put it to use quickly enough!) A pinch of salt and some vanilla extract are the final balancing measures to the filling.
  • Besides the filling, I did tweak the crust just a little using my favorite graham cracker crust. I think it’s the perfect texture and sweetness, so I use it here as well.
  • And finally, the whipped cream on top (which is a must make to cut through the sweetness of the lemon pie) gets some vanilla bean paste added. Vanilla bean paste is my favorite addition to whipped creams and frostings! It gives a slightly stronger and more robust vanilla flavor and it looks beautiful! Vanilla bean paste has actual vanilla beans in it so you’ll see the tiny flecks of black throughout the cream.

More Lemon Desserts:

For more delicious recipes, follow along on PinterestInstagramFacebook, and YouTube ?

FOLLOW ALONG! Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for the latest updates, recipes and content.

Magnolia Lemon Pie

5 from 4 votes
My twist on Joanna Gaine's famous magnolia lemon pie
Print Recipe

Magnolia Lemon Pie

5 from 4 votes
My twist on Joanna Gaine's famous magnolia lemon pie
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Keyword lemon pie
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Chilling 1 hour 30 minutes
Total Time 25 minutes
Servings 1 9-inch pie
Calories 434kcal
Author Chelsea, adapted from Joanna Gaines

Ingredients

Crust:

  • 1 and 1/4 cups (116g) crushed graham crackers about 9 sheets of graham crackers
  • 5 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
  • 1/4 cup (49g) light brown sugar, packed
  • 1/8 teaspoon fine sea salt

Pie Filling:

  • 2 cans (14 ounces EACH) sweetened condensed milk (I use Eagle Brand)
  • 3 large egg yolks
  • 3/4 cup freshly squeezed lemon juice
  • 1 and 1/2 teaspons lemon extract
  • 1/8 teaspoon fine sea salt

Whipped Cream:

  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 1/3 cup powdered sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste
  • Optional: lemon slices/zest, mint sprigs for garnish

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.
  • For the Crust: Spray a 9-inch pie dish with non-stick spray. Combine crushed graham crackers, butter, and sugar in a bowl and mix to combine. Press mixture into the prepared pie plate. Bake in the preheated oven for 8 minutes and set aside to cool.
  • For the Pie Filling: Using a mixer (stand or hand mixers), mix both cans of sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, lemon juice, lemon extract, and salt together. Beat on medium speed for 4-5 minutes. 
  • Pour mixture into the baked pie crust and bake for 10-15 minutes at 350. (Little bubbles will start to surface; cover the crust if it starts to brown too much towards the end. It should only slightly jiggle in the center) Let pie stand at room temperature for 30 minutes.
  • Chill in the refrigerator for at least an hour before serving.
  • For the Whipped Cream: Mix the cream, sugar, and vanilla. Whip until fluffy, and add to cooled lemon pie. You can either smooth it over the entire pie (if the pie will be completely consumed that same day) OR add it to individual pie servings (if the pie won't be eaten all the same day). Do not add cream to the entire pie if you plan on having leftovers as the cream gets watery after being stored. Refrigerate any pie leftovers. If desired garnish slices with lemon zest, a lemon slice, and/or fresh mint. Enjoy right out of the fridge!

Video

Nutrition Facts

Calories: 434kcal

DID YOU MAKE THIS RECIPE?

I love hearing from you when you've made one of my recipes! Tag me on Instagram at @ChelseasMessyApron or leave me a comment below.

The ultimate BEST EVER creamy lemon pie! Based off of Joanna Gaine's famous lemon magnolia pie! via chelseasmessyapron.com #lemon #creamy #pie #dessert #summer #treat #cream #joanna #gaine #magnolia
FREE BONUS

FREE BONUS

EASY MEAL SECRETS:
How to Make Mealtime Hassle Free!

5 secrets to easy, fast and delicious dinners.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Leave a Comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




17 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    Your pics are absolutely amazing! I’ve also had Joanna’s Lemon Pie a handful of times, and you’re right, it definitely does not disappoint. I’ve actually made it for Easter both this past Easter and last year as well. It was a huge hit! Thanks for sharing your tweaks. I’ll have to try it this way next time I make this Lemon Pie!

  2. Hi Chelsea,

    I love a lemon dessert — I’m with you though, I don’t want it to just be yellow and called lemon, I definitely want to taste the flavor. Love that this looks like a recipe kids can help with. Whenever I pull out a bowl, my son always shouts, “I’ll get my stool!” Future chef, right there, lol. Can’t wait to try it!

  3. 5 stars
    what a fun dessert, thank yo for sharing and tweaking this since I hadn’t seen the original, I also love lemon, even lemon scented stuff of all kinds, so this is perfect to round out this extended July holiday with some lovely pie

  4. Just made this tonight for Mother’s Day tomorrow (Sans whipped cream)- excited to try it! I’m curious where the dessert plates are from in your photos? They’re so cute! Thanks!

    1. I hope you love it DeAnna! 🙂 I’m pretty certain the plates were from Crate and Barrel 🙂 Happy Mothers Day!

  5. 5 stars
    I used the zest from the lemons and no extract and it was delicious. Also, made it a 2nd time and only had limes and that worked just as well.

Never Miss a Recipe

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.